- Home
- General Issues
- Demand and Recovery
- Validity of SCN / Order
- Whether order / show cause notice is valid if passed without pre-show cause notice consultation or GST DRC-01 (summary SCN) or GST DRC-01A (tax intimation notice) ?
Whether order / show cause notice is valid if passed without pre-show cause notice consultation or GST DRC-01 (summary SCN) or GST DRC-01A (tax intimation notice) ?
Issue Favourable to Tax Payer ?:- yes
Held - In the absence of a proper show-cause notice the petitioners herein have been denied proper opportunity to defend themselves of the charges. The requirement of affording opportunity of hearing as contemplated in Section 75(4) of the JGST Act has also been denied. Section 75(5) provides that in case sufficient show-cause is shown by the person chargeable with tax, the proper officer shall grant time to the said person and adjourn the hea.....
Issue Favourable to Tax Payer ?:- yes
Held - Order has been passed in violation of principles of natural justice inasmuch as no show cause notice as envisaged in Section 73 or 74 of the TNGST/CGST Act has been issued before passing the order, there is unfairness, unreasonableness in the action of the respondent.
It is seen that after issuance of notice in Form DRC-01A, dated 06.12.2021, the respondent has issued Form GST DRC-01A. Thereafter, if the petitioner has got any o.....
Issue Favourable to Tax Payer ?:- yes
Held - We may also note that with effect from 15.10.2020 i.e., after the impugned show cause notice was issued, Rule 142(1A) has undergone a change, inasmuch as the word ‘shall’ has been replaced with ‘may’. As to what would be the impact of the amendment need not be considered by us in this case, as admittedly the show cause notice was issued prior to 15.10.2020 i.e., on 21.05.2020.
Therefore, having regard to the position which.....
Issue Favourable to Tax Payer ?:- yes
Held - By master circular No.1053/02/2017 dated 10.03.2017, issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs, it is mandatory to issue a pre-show cause notice for consultation, prior to issue of a show cause notice, in cases involving demands of duty above Rs.50,00,000/-(Rupees fifty lakhs only).
A perusal of the above extracted portions of the circular clearly indicates that the pre-show cause notice consultation is made mandatory from.....
Issue Favourable to Tax Payer ?:- yes
Held - This is precisely the reason the Central Board in its master circular dated 10th March, 2017 has directed that the authority, who has issued the pre-consultation notice, should be the authority, who shall issue the show cause notice and adjudicate the same in cases where pre-consultation does not resolve the dispute.
we find that the process of pre-consultation appears to have not been a statutory procedure but a procedure carved .....
Issue Favourable to Tax Payer ?:- yes
Held – While issuing an intimation, the proper officer in the notice could not have said that failure on the part of the noticee may entail the consequence of recovery of the entire amount with penalty and interest.
In the intimation, the dealer should be informed that if he fails to make the payment, the next step in the process will be issue of a show cause notice. Once there is a show cause notice in the Form GST DRC – 01 in.....











