GST - Telangana AAAR: Liquidated damages received by the applicant for delay in commissioning related to production and distribution of electricity is exempt from GST – Decision of Lower authority is set aside [Order attached]

Your free trial / membership plan is expired.
Kindly subscribe to get complete access to indirect tax updates and issue wise cases
Why subscribe to us ?
Get complete access to news updates and download copy of case laws/ notification/ circular etc.
Be a part of our WhatsApp group and read real time indirect tax updates
Access to ready case laws of General Issues and Industry Wide Issues under GST
Access to relevant provisions of law / circular in respect to the issues, along with trail of their amendments
Write your GST query to us for evaluation
Subscription Charges:*
Indirect tax updates -
6 months @299 / 1 Year @499 only
Indirect tax updates + Issue wise cases -
6 months @1199 / 1 Year @1999 only
*Plus applicable GST
Admin
07-Nov-2022 14:15:14
Date of Order: 19.10.2022
Facts:
- The applicant, M/s. Achampet Solar Private Limited, is engaged in production and distribution of electricity obtained from solar energy. They have engaged M/s. Belectric India (P) Ltd for construction of solar power project.
- The agreement has clauses for recovery of liquidated damages on counts, one delay in delivering of the contract and the other regarding non performance of the plant.
- The applicant is desirous of ascertaining the exigibility of liquidated damages to GST on account of the delay in commissioning and its time of supply. Hence this application.
Issue:
- Whether liquidated damages recoverable by the applicant from Belectric India on account of delay in commissioning, qualify as a ‘supply’ under the GST law, thereby attracting the levy of GST?
Order:
- The authorities observed that CBIC has issued Circular No. 178/10/2022-GSTdated:3.8.2022 related to GST applicability on liquidated damages.
- The applicant’s principal supply is the production and distribution of electricity, which is exempt from payment of GST, the liquidated damages received by the applicant towards such supply need to be considered as flow of money without having implication of GST payment.
- According to the circular where the amount awarded as 'liquidated damages' is the amount awarded to compensate the aggrieved party for injury, loss or damage due to breach of contract and there is no contract, express or implied by the aggrieved party.
- Hence, the amount recoverable by the applicant in the form of liquidated damages does not qualify as supply.
- Appeal is disposed off accordingly.
Related Post
Post Category
Your free trial/ membership plan has expired. Kindly subscribe to get complete access of tax news updates.
Why subscribe to us ?
Get complete access to news updates
Access to the Order Copy of the case law/ Notification/ Circular etc
Be a part of our Whatsapp group and read real time tax updates
Access to ready case laws/ circulars on general and industry-wide issues under GST
Submit your GST issues to us for evaluation